SummerOfCodeProposal LuaAI Improvement Nephro

This page is related to Summer of Code 2011

See the list of Summer of Code 2011 Ideas

This is a Summer of Code 2011 student page

Project: SoC Ideas LuaAI 2011

Description

Improving and extending LuaAI

This is a Google Summer of Code 2011 proposal page. I am applying for the LuaAI improvement project. ( By Crab_: http://wiki.wesnoth.org/SoC_Ideas_LuaAI_2011 ). The artificial intelligence module of Battle for Wesnoth is written in C++ and is pretty complicated for scenario developers to configure. That's why Wesnoth developers decided to extend it and allow users to write AI configurations in Lua, which is not possible at the moment.

IRC

Nephro, Nephx

Questionnaire

Basics

1.1) Write a small introduction to yourself. Hello! My name is Dmitry Kovalenko and I am a candidate student for GSoC 2011. I study computing science and hope to become a game developer, because, in my opinion, it is one of the rare industries, where programming is still interesting. I am fond of algorithms and data structures, which combines to an interest in the field of artificial intelligence for games. It's common for the top chess players of the world to play against computer opponents, but who knows, maybe in 5 years, computers will challenge the big names in the computer gaming community.

1.2) State your preferred email address.
nephro dot wes at gmail dot com.
1.3) If you have chosen a nick for IRC and Wesnoth forums, what is it?
IRC: Nephro, nephx(alternative)
Wiki, forums, GNA: Nephro

1.4) Why do you want to participate in summer of code?
I am intending to become a software developer and know the difference between a good and a bad one. It's practice and experience! It isn't possible to become a good programmer by just reading a book and finishing a University, that's why I always take the opportunities to participate in projects, do somebody's homework or just help random people on the net.
Lately I was looking for something more serious to do, even wrote a letter to some lecturers in the Uni, but no one seemed to be interested in my help. I looked up the list of Open Source projects and skimmed through it. Somewhere near the end I noticed BfW and remembered how I used to play the game when travelling to school. I went to the developer channel at freenode and started asking about chances to work on the AI(one of my fields of interest). Someone told me that GSoC is coming and that Crab_ has an AI idea for it and the next thing I know, I am writing answers to this questionnaire.

1.5) What are you studying, subject, level and school?
I am a first year student of Computing Science in the University of Glasgow. Besides programming and general computing topics(information management, HCI, systems) I study Maths and Electronics Engineering.

1.6) What country are you from, at what time are you most likely to be able to join IRC?
During summer I will stay in Latvia, which is my home country, but during term time I live in Glasgow, Scotland. Most likely I turn on my computer in the morning and the IRC client is on for the whole day. If I am programming I am available all the time, from 10 o'clock in the morning till late night, depends on how much do I want to accomplish and when did I start.
The timezone in Latvia is GMT+2, so the European community member should have no difficulties contacting me during daytime.

1.7) Do you have other commitments for the summer period ? Do you plan to take any vacations ? If yes, when.
No, I don't have any commitments at all, except for weekly ballgame matches, but they take place on weekends, so will not affect my work.

Experience

2.1) What programs/software have you worked on before?
Most of the time I developed software for various contests, never had a chance to do my own projects, but I don't regret that, because my "career" was not only challenging and fun, it also provided a wide range of sophisticated tasks, which I had to implement using set technologies and languages, often unsuitable ones. From that I learnt, which languages are good/bad and where can I use them efficiently.
I also had the opportunity to work on a large social network in a real company when I was 17, which I am proud of.

2.2) Have you developed software in a team environment before? (As opposed to hacking on something on your own)
Two of the contests I participated in 12th grade were nationwide team contests. After winning the first one, I got invited to the same team to win the second one. This experience was probably very valuable, I had a chance to learn to evaluate tasks, decide how to distribute the tasks between the team and, of course, complete them in fixed time.
Aside from the contests, I had the experience to work in a professional team(social network mentioned in 2.1). There I learn the importance of documentation, responsibility and of course cleaning up the mess made by bad programmers before us(we received the half made project in a horrible condition). As the youngest member of the team I got to do lots of refactoring, which I started to hate by the end of the summer, but it was still valuable, since i learnt to write reusable generic code from the start, evading the need to refactor later.

2.3) Have you participated to the Google Summer of Code before? As a mentor or a student? In what project? Were you successful? If not, why?
This is my first year in university, therefore my first attempt at GSoC.

2.4) Are you already involved with any open source development projects? If yes, please describe the project and the scope of your involvement.
No, I haven't contributed to any open source projects yet, since I was always busy working or participating in contests.

2.5) Gaming experience - Are you a gamer?
I can't say that I am a gamer. Maybe I was earlier, when I had tons of free time and cared less about programming. Games were always a big part of my life, but those were not always computer games... Maybe the questions below will clear that out.
2.5.1) What type of gamer are you?
Googling "types of gamers" didn't help me :) I don't have a type, I just play when I want and what I want. The game itself doesn't mean a lot to me, I enjoy the challenge, the chance to outplay weaker players or lose to stronger ones.
2.5.2) What type of games?
When I was younger the games changed almost every week, but had the tendency to strategic gameplay. I was keen on Warcraft III TFT, played it competitively, until I understood that at some point your thinking abilities, strategy and tactics don't matter as much as microcontrol(the ability to control single units and small groups in a fight). I like thinking more than clicking the mouse 300 times per minute. Then I moved to WoW, which bored me to death with the quests that are all the same. When I spent ages to level up my character and then understood that I don't like this class, instead of creating a new char I just quit the game.
Then came the DotA family(that's what I call DotA, HoN, LoL and the rest). These games don't need hours of leveling up, don't need 300 clicks per minute, give a chance to think. After travelling between the games of this family I stopped at LoL, the engine of which provides me with what I want: dynamics, speed, flexibility.
2.5.3) What type of opponents do you prefer?
I prefer opponents that are slightly stronger than I am, mostly because beating up young(bad?) players is no fun to me, as well as dieing without a single chance to succeed against hardcore pros.
2.5.4) Are you more interested in story or gameplay?
The short answer would be: gameplay.
In PvP games the story has almost no value, because players concentrate on winning each other. Despite that, a beautiful storyline behind the characters and the world itself can certainly add to the pleasure gained while playing
2.5.5) Have you played Wesnoth? If so, tell us roughly for how long and whether you lean towards single player or multiplayer.
I've found Wesnoth in summer of 2009, when I was working in an office, used to play it during lunch breaks. In autumn, I played it in the train, while travelling to school. My friend noticed that and showed interest, so we started battling each other every morning. Although most of the play time I played single player scenarios, I certainly lean towards multiplayer games, PvP or versus AI.

2.6) If you have contributed any patches to Wesnoth, please list them below. You can also list patches that have been submitted but not committed yet and patches that have not been specifically written for GSoC. If you have gained commit access to our SVN (during the evaluation period or earlier) please state so.
At the moment of writing(28/3/11) I submitted only one patch, the purpose of which was only to get to know the codebase better, experiment with Lua and C++ and just to mark my existence at GNA :)
The patch itself: https://gna.org/patch/?2599

Communication skills

3.1) Though most of our developers are not native English speakers, English is the project's working language. Describe your fluency level in written English.
I think my knowledge of English is sufficient to work on and contribute to Wesnoth. I passed the IELTS test with overall band of 7.5 and study in Scotland, where everything takes place in English.

3.2) What spoken languages are you fluent in?
Russian(native)
Latvian(as good as native)
English(fluent)

3.3) Are you good at interacting with other players? Our developer community is friendly, but the player community can be a bit rough.
I am good at interacting with players, who are good at interacting with players :) If the team is passive I usually try to start some tactical discussions, give advice to players, who aren't doing too good. If they are active and polite we manage to interact pretty well, but people, who start insulting others usually get punished by not receiving help from me(which is very important in teamplay games like LoL). The enemies, well, I always admire people, who outplay me with style and beauty, and I always tell them that, but most of the time I hear bad things in my address and I may sometimes verbally fight back, using this as a psychological weapon to make the enemies more unstable and willing to punish me.

3.4) Do you give constructive advice?
I usually try to help people with constructive advice if I feel that they want to hear it, but as practice shows, not everybody is interested in argumented and constructive advice as much as they want to hear a plain answer to their question.
3.5) Do you receive advice well?
I think that I do, I learnt that from my other hobby, electronic music production, where the first steps were very tough, and the criticism received - as rough as it can get. But I managed to get through that point and now I will never ask for an answer, I'll ask for the reason.
3.6) Are you good at sorting useful criticisms from useless ones?
It can sometimes get tricky, but I usually find respected people in the community and listen to them first, since they are less likely to give obviously bad advice. My experience in programming also allows me to understand, whether the given advice is a good idea or not.
3.7) How autonomous are you when developing ? Would you rather discuss intensively changes and not start coding until you know what you want to do or would you rather code a proof of concept to "see how it turn out", taking the risk of having it thrown away if it doesn't match what the project want
I do not like the "see how it turns out" approach, because that led me to tons of refactoring of my code(and code of other people). I'd rather spend 5 minutes of a more experienced programmer to find out what I am asked to do, then spend 20 minutes of him explaining to me what have I done wrong and why, and how to fix it now. Time investments before starting the work will almost always lead to time economy later.

Project

4.1)Did you select a project from our list? If that is the case, what project did you select? What do you want to especially concentrate on?
I selected Crab's project on improving and extending the AI of BfW(http://wiki.wesnoth.org/SoC_Ideas_LuaAI_2011), since AI is one of my fields of interest and this is the perfect opportunity to learn, how real AIs actually work. The experience on developing and investigating the current AI will let me not make mistakes in the future. in my opinion, game AI is one of the most fun programming spheres out there.
I want to concentrate on the last part of the idea: the interaction between the AI teams. That seems very challenging and even more fun, but to get there, of course, I will have to work efficiently to complete the other tasks in time.
4.2) If you have invented your own project, please describe the project and the scope.
-- not relevant --
4.3) Why did you choose this project?
AI(as I stated many times before) is a very fun programming topic, in my opinion, but I never really had a chance to try myself out in it. Wesnoth is a complicated positional strategy, where discrete analysis fails and any AI solution that can fight against a human mind must be a peace of art.
4.4) Include an estimated timeline for your work on the project. Don't forget to mention special things like "I booked holidays between A and B" and "I got an exam at ABC and won't be doing much then".
I don't have any significant plans for the summer. I have two trainings a week, both in the evenings and some matches that always take place on Saturdays and Sundays.

Task	Date	Comment
Lua library of low-level functions	July 15	This part MUST be completed by the mid-term evaluation deadline.
Lua library of high-level functions	August 1	The date is the most pessimistic allowed, actually I hope to complete it by the middle of July, meaning that I complete the low-level part much faster than said in the timeline.
AI improvement	Undefined	The task is pretty vague at the moment, but I'll describe it in more detail below

AI improvement: there are some AI improvements proposed by Crab_ in his idea page, but those are not obligatory to be done. Instead, he said he welcomes discussion about interesting ideas in the AI field.

4.5) Include as much technical detail about your implementation as you can

• Technical details to be added here.*
  

One of the ideas I wanted to implement myself, was creating a "brain" for Wesnoth. The "brain" would be a horribly sophisticated data structure that could help the RCA AI evaluate candidate moves. The "brain" would "think" in a different thread and answer to RCA requests depending on the current state. While the player makes his moves, the "brain" would constantly rebalance itself by doing positional and discrete analysis. The positional analysis would allow the AI to have a plan, and that would make it much more stronger than it is now. Discrete analysis is a bad solution for Wesnoth, because it would take forever to calculate even a small part of the possible moves, but if we have a pre-planned position the discrete analysis would boost it, find the holes in it and patch them up.
4.6) What do you expect to gain from this project?
Tons of experience, friends and confidence in my programming skills. The stipend is also very tempting, since I study abroad and life in Glasgow is much more expensive that in Latvia. It would help me concentrate on my studies and think less about part time jobs and other money matters.

4.7) What would make you stay in the Wesnoth community after the conclusion of SOC?
Instead of answering this question directly, I will tell you what would make me leave the Wesnoth community :) I would leave if senior devs would reject my ideas and proposals. Wesnoth is a perfect project for aspiring developers to try out their skills. My numerous ideas for the AI are impossible to implement during one summer, and since I have a lot of free time during my studies at University, I will most certainly continue making the AI more powerful than it is at the moment in autumn, winter and spring(or even this summer, if I don't get accepted :D)

Practical considerations

5.1) Are you familiar with any of the following tools or languages?

• Subversion (used for all commits) -- I have used Mercurial for my work and I doubt that I will not be able to use SVN after reading the manual
• C++ (language used for all the normal source code) -- I took a course on C++, read books on it and still have a lot to learn there. My favorite language.
• STL, Boost, Sdl (C++ libraries used by Wesnoth) -- STL is used in all my projects, therefore I can find my way around it. I haven't used Boost a lot, but remember refactoring a peace of code that used it extensively. Again, nothing is impossible, while we have the manuals. I used SDL only once, for a simple ping-pong game, know the basic concepts, but don't think that this library is at all relevant to AI development.
• Python (optional, mainly used for tools) -- took a course on python and currently finished studying it at university. Not a fan of it, but it's very useful in some cases, when you have to write something small, fast, inefficient, insecure...(j.k. everything depends on the developer)
• build environments (eg cmake/scons) -- didn't have experience with such before, but successfully compiled Wesnoth in Linux and Windows(windows was a pain, but the solution was out there)...
• WML (the wesnoth specific scenario language) -- not at all, yet. Hopefully it isn't a big problem, there still is time to learn.
• Lua (used in combination with WML to create scenarios) -- learnt Lua in the beginning of March, after talking with Wesnoth's crew for the first time.

5.2) Which tools do you normally use for development? Why do you use them?
I like to use simple IDE's, not overstuffed with tools. I used Dev-C++ for a long time, but it had problems, that's why I transfered to Code::Blocks, which seems like a fine IDE to me atm. For Wesnoth I use MSVC9, because it is easy to compile Wesnoth in it and it also seems comfortable. I prefer Linux for development, but don't have a possibility to use a Linux machine.

5.3) What programming languages are you fluent in?
C/C++ - constantly use them and try to deepen my knowledge on every occasion.
Pascal - my first language, which I was taught to program in.
Python - fluent, but not a fan.
Java - basic knowledge, am able to create small simple applications, with a simple GUI.
PHP - used for work on a social network, don't like it, though.
Other languages are not worth mentioning.

5.4) Would you mind talking with your mentor on telephone / internet phone?
No, not at all. I do not have a phone number in Latvia at the moment, but I will post one here as soon as I get one.