GCI/Playtesting/The Hammer of Thursagan/Challenging: Difference between revisions
From The Battle for Wesnoth Wiki
< GCI | Playtesting
Created page with '(to be filled out by playtester)' |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
(to be | == Preamble == | ||
Google Code-In 2010. | |||
This page shows the results of testing The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.3 - campaign "The Hammer of Thursagan " on Challenging (Hard) difficulty. | |||
I followed the guidelines on [http://wiki.wesnoth.org/GCI/Playtesting this page] for the analysis. | |||
The following has been quoted from the page for reference purposes: | |||
<blockquote> | |||
#What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on? | |||
#How difficult did you find the scenario? (1-10) | |||
#How clear did you find the scenario objectives? | |||
#How clear and interesting did you find the dialog and storyline of the scenario? | |||
#What were your major challenges in meeting the objectives of the scenario? | |||
#How fun do you think the scenario is? (1-10) | |||
#What, if any, are changes you would have made to the scenario to make it more fun? | |||
#Was there any event that caused you to lose the game and forced you to reload or restart the scenario? | |||
#If you know a bit of the Wesnoth Markup Language - do you think that the WML of this scenario is clear and well commented? If not which part would you like to be documented better? | |||
</blockquote> | |||
== Scenario 1: At The East Gate == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 4. It was very easy but it’s normal for firs scenario in the campaign. | |||
#Very clear scenario objectives. | |||
#The dialog is short but clear. | |||
#There were no challenges to meeting objectives of this scenario. | |||
#Fun: 6. Easy and very fun scenario. | |||
#No changes needed. The scenario is very good. | |||
#No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario. | |||
#I don’t know nothing about WML so I can’t give a comment. In the scenarios below I will miss this point. | |||
== Reclaiming The Past == | |||
In this cutscene there was only dialog and I found a mistake. In the beginning, when the map is shown, the sentence begins with minuscule(audience) instead of capital letter(Audience). | |||
== Scenario 2: Strange Allies == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 5. The alliance with the orcs is very helpful and the scenario was very easy. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Very good dialog. | |||
#No challenges to meeting objectives. | |||
#Fun: 6. As the previous one – very good. | |||
#No changes needed. Good scenario for leveling up your units. | |||
#No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario. | |||
== Scenario 3: Troll Bridge == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 5. Not so hard scenario. If you recall high level units and use them properly there would be no problems here. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Short but well written dialog. | |||
#No challenges to meeting objectives. | |||
#Fun: 6. | |||
#The dialog could be extended. | |||
#None. | |||
== Scenario 4: Invaders == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 7. The hardest scenario from the beginning of the campaign. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Good dialog. | |||
#The major challenges were the big number of enemy units. It was very hard to fight with orcs and bandits at once. | |||
#Fun: 5. Hard and not so fun scenario. | |||
#No changes. | |||
#Several restarts because of hero’s dying or changing game tactic. | |||
== Scenario 5: High Pass == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 6. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Good and well written dialog. | |||
#Fun: 7. | |||
#No changes. Another well made scenario. | |||
#I restarted once because of hero’s death. | |||
== Scenario 6: Mages and Drakes == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 5. | |||
#No problem with scenario objectives. | |||
#The dialog was fine. | |||
#The union with the mages made the scenario very easy. With their help and lots of high-leveled units I defeated the Drake leader with no problems. | |||
#Fun: 7. | |||
#Very nice scenario. No changes needed. | |||
#No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario. | |||
== Scenario 7: Fear == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 6. Not so hard scenario. | |||
#Clear objectives. | |||
#Very interesting and well-written dialog. | |||
#No challenges to meeting objectives. With correct tactic is very easy to defeat the enemy leader. | |||
#Fun: 7. Another very interesting scenario. The burned villages was very impressive. | |||
#No changes needed. | |||
#No problems. | |||
== Scenario 8: Forbidden Forest == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 7. Very hard scenario. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#The dialog was well written, but not so interesting as previous one. | |||
#The major challenges were Fog of War and high-leveled enemy units. It was very hard do defense Aiglondur and Angarthing from three sides until they reach to the signpost. The terrain caused me additional troubles. | |||
#Fun: 7. Very fun and interesting scenario. It took me a lot of time to finish it. | |||
#Nothing to change, it’s very well made. | |||
#Restarted several times because dying of Aiglondur or Angarthing. | |||
== Scenario 9: The Siege of Kal Kartha == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 6. Not so easy scenario. | |||
#Clear objectives – kill them all! | |||
#Well written and interesting dialog. Here begins the culmination of the campaign. | |||
#No problems to meeting objectives. The union with the dwarves was very helpful. All enemies were focused to my ally and it wasn’t so hard to defeat their unguarded leaders. | |||
#Fun: 6. | |||
#No changes needed. | |||
#None. | |||
== Scenario 10: The Court of Karrag == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 4. Very easy scenario. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Very good and interesting dialog. No mistakes. | |||
#No challenges to meeting objectives. This scenario is almost story only. | |||
#Fun: 7. Very fun scenario. It differs from the others. | |||
#No changes. Very good scenario. | |||
#No. | |||
== Scenario 11: The Underlevels == | |||
#Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3. | |||
#Scenario difficulty: 9. The hardest and the longest scenario in the campaign. | |||
#Clear scenario objectives. | |||
#Good dialog. | |||
#The major challenge was that the scenario was very long. I spent a lot of time playing it but finally I made it. | |||
#Fun: 7. Good scenario | |||
#No changes needed. | |||
#No restarts. | |||
Revision as of 22:06, 3 January 2011
Preamble
Google Code-In 2010. This page shows the results of testing The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.3 - campaign "The Hammer of Thursagan " on Challenging (Hard) difficulty. I followed the guidelines on this page for the analysis.
The following has been quoted from the page for reference purposes:
- What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on?
- How difficult did you find the scenario? (1-10)
- How clear did you find the scenario objectives?
- How clear and interesting did you find the dialog and storyline of the scenario?
- What were your major challenges in meeting the objectives of the scenario?
- How fun do you think the scenario is? (1-10)
- What, if any, are changes you would have made to the scenario to make it more fun?
- Was there any event that caused you to lose the game and forced you to reload or restart the scenario?
- If you know a bit of the Wesnoth Markup Language - do you think that the WML of this scenario is clear and well commented? If not which part would you like to be documented better?
Scenario 1: At The East Gate
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 4. It was very easy but it’s normal for firs scenario in the campaign.
- Very clear scenario objectives.
- The dialog is short but clear.
- There were no challenges to meeting objectives of this scenario.
- Fun: 6. Easy and very fun scenario.
- No changes needed. The scenario is very good.
- No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario.
- I don’t know nothing about WML so I can’t give a comment. In the scenarios below I will miss this point.
Reclaiming The Past
In this cutscene there was only dialog and I found a mistake. In the beginning, when the map is shown, the sentence begins with minuscule(audience) instead of capital letter(Audience).
Scenario 2: Strange Allies
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 5. The alliance with the orcs is very helpful and the scenario was very easy.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Very good dialog.
- No challenges to meeting objectives.
- Fun: 6. As the previous one – very good.
- No changes needed. Good scenario for leveling up your units.
- No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario.
Scenario 3: Troll Bridge
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 5. Not so hard scenario. If you recall high level units and use them properly there would be no problems here.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Short but well written dialog.
- No challenges to meeting objectives.
- Fun: 6.
- The dialog could be extended.
- None.
Scenario 4: Invaders
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 7. The hardest scenario from the beginning of the campaign.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Good dialog.
- The major challenges were the big number of enemy units. It was very hard to fight with orcs and bandits at once.
- Fun: 5. Hard and not so fun scenario.
- No changes.
- Several restarts because of hero’s dying or changing game tactic.
Scenario 5: High Pass
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 6.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Good and well written dialog.
- Fun: 7.
- No changes. Another well made scenario.
- I restarted once because of hero’s death.
Scenario 6: Mages and Drakes
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 5.
- No problem with scenario objectives.
- The dialog was fine.
- The union with the mages made the scenario very easy. With their help and lots of high-leveled units I defeated the Drake leader with no problems.
- Fun: 7.
- Very nice scenario. No changes needed.
- No events caused me to lose the game or reload the scenario.
Scenario 7: Fear
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 6. Not so hard scenario.
- Clear objectives.
- Very interesting and well-written dialog.
- No challenges to meeting objectives. With correct tactic is very easy to defeat the enemy leader.
- Fun: 7. Another very interesting scenario. The burned villages was very impressive.
- No changes needed.
- No problems.
Scenario 8: Forbidden Forest
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 7. Very hard scenario.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- The dialog was well written, but not so interesting as previous one.
- The major challenges were Fog of War and high-leveled enemy units. It was very hard do defense Aiglondur and Angarthing from three sides until they reach to the signpost. The terrain caused me additional troubles.
- Fun: 7. Very fun and interesting scenario. It took me a lot of time to finish it.
- Nothing to change, it’s very well made.
- Restarted several times because dying of Aiglondur or Angarthing.
Scenario 9: The Siege of Kal Kartha
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 6. Not so easy scenario.
- Clear objectives – kill them all!
- Well written and interesting dialog. Here begins the culmination of the campaign.
- No problems to meeting objectives. The union with the dwarves was very helpful. All enemies were focused to my ally and it wasn’t so hard to defeat their unguarded leaders.
- Fun: 6.
- No changes needed.
- None.
Scenario 10: The Court of Karrag
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 4. Very easy scenario.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Very good and interesting dialog. No mistakes.
- No challenges to meeting objectives. This scenario is almost story only.
- Fun: 7. Very fun scenario. It differs from the others.
- No changes. Very good scenario.
- No.
Scenario 11: The Underlevels
- Campaign difficulty: Hard. Version: 1.9.3.
- Scenario difficulty: 9. The hardest and the longest scenario in the campaign.
- Clear scenario objectives.
- Good dialog.
- The major challenge was that the scenario was very long. I spent a lot of time playing it but finally I made it.
- Fun: 7. Good scenario
- No changes needed.
- No restarts.
This page was last edited on 3 January 2011, at 22:06.