GCI/Playtesting/Delfadors Memours/Normal - Revision history

Aethaeryn: categorizing

2011-03-06T02:59:10Z

categorizing

2010-12-12T03:07:52Z

‎Summary: m

2010-12-12T03:06:21Z

finished campaign testing

2010-12-12T02:40:30Z

‎Scenario 22: Face of the Enemy: last scenario (22)

2010-12-12T02:11:25Z

‎Scenario 21: Clash at the Manor: scen 21

2010-12-12T01:44:06Z

‎Scenario 20: Prince of Wesnoth: scen 20

2010-12-12T00:47:09Z

‎Scenario 19: Showdown in the Northern Swamp: scen 19

2010-12-11T03:37:18Z

‎Scenario 18: The Portal of Doom: scen 18

2010-12-11T02:06:12Z

‎Scenario 17: A New Ally: scen 17

2010-12-11T01:40:49Z

‎Scenario 16: Dark Sky Over Weldyn: scen 16

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:59, 6 March 2011
Line 286:		Line 286:

	'''Post scriptum:''' There appears to be a typo in the name of this page. --[[User:S.Lee94\|S.Lee94]] 03:07, 12 December 2010 (UTC)		'''Post scriptum:''' There appears to be a typo in the name of this page. --[[User:S.Lee94\|S.Lee94]] 03:07, 12 December 2010 (UTC)
		+
		+	[[Category: GCI]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:07, 12 December 2010
Line 284:		Line 284:

	I found Delfador's Memoirs to be an excellent campaign. While the gameplay was entertaining to play, I especially like the storyline and how it developed. It fit well with both the campaigns before and after it (chronologically), and was also good at expanding Delfador's character to more than just the archetypal "wise old mage". This campaign is another great addition to the Battle Of Wesnoth universe. --[[User:S.Lee94\|S.Lee94]] 03:06, 12 December 2010 (UTC)		I found Delfador's Memoirs to be an excellent campaign. While the gameplay was entertaining to play, I especially like the storyline and how it developed. It fit well with both the campaigns before and after it (chronologically), and was also good at expanding Delfador's character to more than just the archetypal "wise old mage". This campaign is another great addition to the Battle Of Wesnoth universe. --[[User:S.Lee94\|S.Lee94]] 03:06, 12 December 2010 (UTC)
		+
		+	'''Post scriptum:''' There appears to be a typo in the name of this page. --[[User:S.Lee94\|S.Lee94]] 03:07, 12 December 2010 (UTC)

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-= WORK IN PROGRESS =
+== Preamble ==
-== Preamble ==
+[[GCI/Playtesting|For reference]]:
 <blockquote>
 #What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on?
@@ Line 282: / Line 282: @@
 == Summary ==

@@ Line 272: / Line 272: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 2.
+#Objectives clear.
+#No major challenges.
+#A good ending to this scenario.
+#Fun: 5.
+#This level might be too easy for the last level.
+#Delfador and Kalenz are able to easily kill the enemy archers, which allows them to just keep coming and eventually kill them.
+#Looks good.
 == Summary ==

@@ Line 260: / Line 260: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 4.
+#Objectives were mostly clear, the part where I had to find the secret entrance was confusing.
+#No major challenges.
+#Storyline is very interesting, I never thought Delfador would take such extreme measures.
+#Fun: 6.
+#No changes needed.
+#None.
+#Good.
 == Scenario 22: Face of the Enemy ==

@@ Line 248: / Line 248: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 6.
+#Objectives clear.
+#Keeping all my units alive is difficult. I have very limited gold (I seem to always end negative) and I can't afford to replace any units.
+#The story is very interesting. Also, I'm wondering if any campaigns explains the origin of the book.
+#Fun: 7.
+#I think the play could be given slightly more gold.
+#I fell for the trap of sending all my units into the forest in the middle the first time, and they died.
+#The code is very clear and well commented, although I think Kalenz's monologue for the time over event could have been less melodramatic.
 == Scenario 21: Clash at the Manor ==

@@ Line 236: / Line 236: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 6.
+#Objectives were clear.
+#The first night, when you're outnumbered 3-2 is difficult, but afterwards it's easy to overwelm the enemy. The trick where you hold onto the north bridge makes things easier.
+#The dialogue near the end was good foreshadowing of the other campaigns.
+#Fun: 5.
+#No changes needed.
+#None.
+#Code is clear.
 == Scenario 20: Prince of Wesnoth ==

@@ Line 224: / Line 224: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 7.
+#Objectives were clear.
+#The hardest part was getting Delfador back to the cave enterance. It takes a whole 8 turns, during which he can easily be killed. I was only able to make it by sacrificing a Steelclad and the Dwarvish Lord that was given in the beginning, and even then just barely.
+#Storyline is good.
+#Fun: 2.
+#Going through the icy ground to the portal and back was painful, I think a couple of non-frozen tiles could be added to make it easier.
+#See challenges above.
+#Looks good.
 == Scenario 19: Showdown in the Northern Swamp ==

@@ Line 212: / Line 212: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#Difficulty: 2. An easy scenario for a change.
+#Objectives clear.
+#No major challenges.
+#Storyline is proceeding as expected, we get to the dwarves. I haven't seen them at all this campaign until now.
+#Fun: 4.
+#No changes needed.
+#None.
+#Code looks good. I found the event occures when Delfador kills unit humourous.
 == Scenario 18: The Portal of Doom ==

@@ Line 200: / Line 200: @@
 #Version 1.9.2. Mage (Normal) Difficulty.
+#N/A
+#N/A
+#N/A
+#The dialogue felt very forced. At first, the king talks about how inexperienced Delfador is and how he knows what he's doing, then suddenly half the army gets slaughtered, the king is desparate for help, and Delfador is giving orders to the king. It just seems to be an excuse to take away an assured victory, and I don't get the feeling of time having past. It would take a bit of work, but I'd suggest adding a scene showing the battle and how the army lost instead of just this short paragraph. At the very least, the dialogue should be reworked.
+#N/A
+#N/A
+#N/A
+#Code is fine.
 == Scenario 17: A New Ally ==