Difference between revisions of "GCI/Playtesting/Legend of Wesmere/Easy"

Revision as of 20:31, 3 December 2010

(to be filled out by playtester)

Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty) questions.

  1. What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on?
  2. How difficult did you find the scenario? (1-10)
  3. How clear did you find the scenario objectives?
  4. How clear and interesting did you find the dialog and storyline of the scenario?
  5. What were your major challenges in meeting the objectives of the scenario?
  6. How fun do you think the scenario is? (1-10)
  7. What, if any, are changes you would have made to the scenario to make it more fun?
  8. Was there any event that caused you to lose the game and forced you to reload or restart the scenario?
  9. If you know a bit of the Wesnoth Markup Language - do you think that the WML of this scenario is clear and well commented? If not which part would you like to be

documented better?

scenario 1: 01_The_Uprooting

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Very clear.

4.The storyline was clear and made the story more interesting,it was great for the start of the campaign.

5.No major challanges,just needed a better positioning ,thus the difficulty.

6.5/10

7.None really.

8.None.

9.Clear and intuitive,well commented.

scenario 2: 02_Hostile_mountains

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Clear.

4.A nice change of scenery,from the previous scenario.

5.None.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 3: 03_Kalian

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.The storyline was great,and made this the most fun scenario.

5.No major challanges.

6.8/10

7.No changes needed,it was a solid scenario.

8.None.

9.Well written.

scenario 4: 04_Elvish_Treasury

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Clear

4.Intereresting,both the storyline and the dialog.

5.None.

6.5/10

7.None

8.None

9.Clear,well commented.

scenario 5: 05_Saurian_Treasury

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.very clear

4.Good

5.No major challanges

6.5/10

7.None

8.None

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 6: 06_Acquaintance_in_Need

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.4/10

3.Clear,not to be misunderstood.

4.Good

5.No major challanges

6.6/10

7.None

8.None

9.Very clear.

scenario 7: 07_Elves_last_stand

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.4/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.No challanges to meeting the scenario objectives.

6.5/10

7.None

8.None

9.Clearly written and well commented

scenario 8: 08_Council_of_hard_choices

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Decent

5.Easy enough,with no major challanges.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear.

scenario 9: 09_Bounty_hunters

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Clear.

4.Good.

5.No challanges to meeting the objectives.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear,well commented.

scenario 10: 10_Cliffs_of_Thoria

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Clear.

4.Very interesting.

5.No significant challenges.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks good.

scenario 11: 11_Battle_of_the_book

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.Haven't encountered major challanges.

6.7/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 12: 12_Revelations

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Clear.

4.Good.

5.No particullar challange

6.5/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks good.

scenario 13: 13_News_from_the_front

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.4/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.No particular challange.

6.5/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear.

scenario 14: 14_Human_Alliance

1. Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.5/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.No major challange.

6.5/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear.

scenario 15: 15_The_Treaty

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.No major challange.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 16: 16_The_Chief_must_die

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.No major challange.

6.7/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 17: 17_Breaking_the_siege

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.No major challange.

6.7/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Clear and well commented.

scenario 18: 18_Hour_of_Glory

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.Haven't encountered major challanges.

6.5/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks good.

scenario 19: 19_Costly_Revenge

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.No major challange.

6.6/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks very clear.

scenario 20: 20_Council_ruling

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.6/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.Haven't encountered major challanges.

6.5/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks good.

scenario 21: 21_Elvish_Assassins

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Clear objectives.

4.Good.

5.No major challange.

6.7/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks good.

scenario 22: 22_Northern_Battle

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.7/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.No major challange.

6.7/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.The objectives in the code do not match the objectives displayed.The defeat of Lanadar by death does not make the player victorious,as explained in the objectives.

scenario 23: 23_End_of_War

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.8/10

3.Very clear objectives.

4.Interesting.

5.Haven't encountered major challanges.

6.8/10

7.None.

8.None.

9.Looks fine.

scenario 24: 24_Epilogue

1.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.

2.n/a

3.n/a

4.n/a

5.n/a

6.n/a

7.n/a

8.n/a

9.n/a

Andrei Parau,GCI 2010.

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty)
+questions.
+. What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on?
+. How difficult did you find the scenario? (1-10)
+. How clear did you find the scenario objectives?
+. How clear and interesting did you find the dialog and storyline of the scenario?
+. What were your major challenges in meeting the objectives of the scenario?
+. How fun do you think the scenario is? (1-10)
+. What, if any, are changes you would have made to the scenario to make it more fun?
+. Was there any event that caused you to lose the game and forced you to reload or restart the scenario?
+. If you know a bit of the Wesnoth Markup Language - do you think that the WML of this scenario is clear and well commented? If not which part would you like to be
-)Bugs:
+documented better?
--chapter 3: Part one title  '/npart1'
--chapter 3: 'Northern Battle' scenario : By Killing the enemy leader 'Lanadar',by simultaneously furfilling all the scenario objectives ,I was defeated.
-)What difficulty levels and what version of Wesnoth have you played the scenario on?
-Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
-)How difficult did you find the scenario? (1-10)
+	'''scenario 1: 01_The_Uprooting'''
-The overall difficulty was around 6-8,6 being the easiest scenarios of this campaign,8 being the hardest.
-)How clear did you find the scenario objectives?
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
-The scenario objectives were clear to me and I believe that they can't create confusion,even to those who don't have too much knowledge of english.
-)How clear and interesting did you find the dialog and storyline of the scenario?
+.7/10
-To be honest,I didn't expect a free game to have such a good storyline.It's gripping and it makes you want to keep playing.
-)What were your major challenges in meeting the objectives of the scenario?
+.Very clear.
-Positioning,holding as many villages as possible in order to ensure the gold-flow.
-)How fun do you think the scenario is? (1-10)
+.The storyline was clear and made the story more interesting,it was great for the start of the campaign.
-For a scenario built by simple means graphics-wise,but with solid gameplay I'd say 8 would be a fair
-mark.But of course,there is always room for improvement :).
-)What, if any, are changes you would have made to the scenario to make it more fun?
+.No major challanges,just needed a better positioning ,thus the difficulty.
-Well , the overall story was great,so I wouldn't change that.The only thing that I didn't particularly enjoy was the rather dull beginning of the Campaign ,when you start with only 2 types of units.But I guess it's mandatory to do so ,in order to unlock a variety of units while you move forward in the game.
-)Was there any event that caused you to lose the game and forced you to reload or restart the scenario?
+.5/10
-Getting outplayed by the AI.If I were a person with a lot of free time ,I'd really want to try out the harder difficulties of the game.
-On 23rd November 2010 17:14, by Iurii Chernyi:
+.None really.
+.None.
+.Clear and intuitive,well commented.
+'''scenario 2: 02_Hostile_mountains'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Clear.
+.A nice change of scenery,from the previous scenario.
+.None.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 3: 03_Kalian'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.The storyline was great,and made this the most fun scenario.
+.No major challanges.
+.8/10
+.No changes needed,it was a solid scenario.
+.None.
+.Well written.
+'''scenario 4: 04_Elvish_Treasury'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Clear
+.Intereresting,both the storyline and the dialog.
+.None.
+.5/10
+.None
+.None
+.Clear,well commented.
+'''scenario 5: 05_Saurian_Treasury'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.very clear
+.Good
+.No major challanges
+.5/10
+.None
+.None
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 6: 06_Acquaintance_in_Need'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.4/10
+.Clear,not to be misunderstood.
+.Good
+.No major challanges
+.6/10
+.None
+.None
+.Very clear.
+'''scenario 7: 07_Elves_last_stand'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.4/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.No challanges to meeting the scenario objectives.
+.5/10
+.None
+.None
+.Clearly written and well commented
+'''scenario 8: 08_Council_of_hard_choices'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Decent
+.Easy enough,with no major challanges.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear.
+'''scenario 9: 09_Bounty_hunters'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Clear.
+.Good.
+.No challanges to meeting the objectives.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear,well commented.
+'''scenario 10: 10_Cliffs_of_Thoria'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Clear.
+.Very interesting.
+.No significant challenges.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks good.
+'''scenario 11: 11_Battle_of_the_book'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.Haven't encountered major challanges.
+.7/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 12: 12_Revelations'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Clear.
+.Good.
+.No particullar challange
+.5/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks good.
+'''scenario 13: 13_News_from_the_front'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.4/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.No particular challange.
+.5/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear.
+'''scenario 14: 14_Human_Alliance'''
+. Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.5/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.No major challange.
+.5/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear.
+'''scenario 15: 15_The_Treaty'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.No major challange.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 16: 16_The_Chief_must_die'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.7/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.No major challange.
+.7/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 17: 17_Breaking_the_siege'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.7/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.No major challange.
+.7/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Clear and well commented.
+'''scenario 18: 18_Hour_of_Glory'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.7/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.Haven't encountered major challanges.
+.5/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks good.
+'''scenario 19: 19_Costly_Revenge'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.No major challange.
+.6/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks very clear.
+'''scenario 20: 20_Council_ruling'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.6/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.Haven't encountered major challanges.
+.5/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks good.
+'''scenario 21: 21_Elvish_Assassins'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.7/10
+.Clear objectives.
+.Good.
+.No major challange.
+.7/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks good.
+'''scenario 22: 22_Northern_Battle'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.7/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.No major challange.
+.7/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.The objectives in the code do not match the objectives displayed.The defeat of Lanadar by death
+does not make the player victorious,as explained in the objectives.
+'''scenario 23: 23_End_of_War'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.8/10
+.Very clear objectives.
+.Interesting.
+.Haven't encountered major challanges.
+.8/10
+.None.
+.None.
+.Looks fine.
+'''scenario 24: 24_Epilogue'''
+.Legends of Wesmere(easy difficulty),The Battle for Wesnoth 1.9.2.
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
+.n/a
-You will also need to verify the following points:
-    * Gold and unit carryover is done correctly between the scenarios.
-          o Scenario 3 is the most critical point, there we have a protagonist switch for both players.
-    * Objectives
-          o The objectives communicated to the player match with the implemented scenario objectives.
-          o The prose does also match to the objectives.
-    * Difficulty is appropriate for the chosen difficult level.
--Gold and units were carried on between the scenarios,I haven't encountered any bugs in this area.
--The objectives were clear ,and the prose matched very well the objectives.
--The difficulty was a good part of the gameplay,it wasn't so easy that you would eventually get bored but also not too hard(I tend to believe that too hard meaning to replay the same scenario for over 5-6 hours,and still not managing to win).
 Andrei Parau,GCI 2010.